The Murder of Anna Wiese
Green Mountain, Iowa

EVENING TIMES REPUBLICAN

SATURDAY, SEPTEMBER 15, 1894

HEADLINES

SEPTEMBER 15, 1894

THE BENNETT TRIAL

The Week Closes Without Material Development on Either Side

New Witnesses for the Defense - A Hair Expert on the Stand Today

Important Disclosure Predicted - Break of a Juror

STATUS OF THE MURDER CASE

No Sensational Developments So Far - Two or Three Days More of Testimony

This is the ninth day of the Bennett murder trial. There have been few features so far and no extraordinary or sensational developments whatever. It will be remembered that on the former trial people were on the tip toe of expectancy, waiting for some startling disclosure that never came. The most sensational feature of the case at that time was its abrupt termination and its cause. One of the jurors, exhausted by the length and fatigue of the trial and over sixty hours of deliberation in the jury room, went into violent convulsions and the case at once ended in a disagreement. There has been gossip on the streets and in business places that something will “drop,” and that it will cause big excitement before the termination of the present trial. So far, however, there has not been the slightest indication of it in the proceedings. The week closes with a larger part of the evidence in on the part of defense, but it will take two or three days longer to close the testimony. The defense will probably get through by Tuesday evening, and a few hours will be occupied in the introduction of rebuttal. It may therefore require about another week to reach the final result.

The defense introduced an expert on hair this afternoon in the person of Irving J. Smith, professor of pathology and histology in the State Agricultural College. His testimony was to the effect that there is no material difference in the texture of hair taken from the heads of Anna Wiese and the defendant, and that it would be practically impossible to identify hair by color or other ordinary characteristics.

FRIDAY AFTERNOON CONTINUED

Bessie McKerral – Was witness for the state. Summer before she was murdered Anna weighed about 135 pounds; was five feet nine; have seen her scuffle with young men; she seemed to be about as strong as they were. (A juror here “spoke right out in meeting” and asked the court what they were expected to believe. Here are witnesses testifying on both sides,” he said, “and for my part I don’t know on which side they are telling the truth.” The court and everybody else laughed, and when the judge regained his composure he informed the perplexed juror that he would give them full instructions on that and other points before they were sent out.) Witness said that while she worked for Mrs. Hill, after the murder, the latter told her that it looked terrible at E. N. Hill’s this morning after the crime, that everything was covered with blood and that it was all over the back porch.

Frank Stulke – Live in Beaman. Was in the slough east of place of murder about day light, morning after the crime. Shot a chicken some eighty rods east of there; the sun rose as we reached the road running east of Bennett’s. Coroner’s jury were in the house when we left Rusie’s.

John McKerrel – Anna Wiese was a hard working girl, was muscular and stronger than the ordinary working girl. Saw Mr. Ricker take some hair from the head of Anna Wiese. It was placed in envelopes and handed to Mr. Ricker, at cemetery.

Cross – Mr. Caswell held the envelopes; Ricker placed the hair in the envelopes, four of them; was not aware of hair being taken from the girl’s hand. Don’t think any hair from the hand was put in the envelopes. There was a whispered conversation, something about some other hair, and what they better do about it.

Re-direct – Am reasonably certain that the hair was in no way mixed before being put in the envelopes, as I saw it clipped off and carried to the envelopes.

A. J. Jackson – There was a singing at my place the night of the murder. Powers, Lowe and Dan Rusie left about 10 o’clock, probably ten minutes before.

J. W. Lynch – Live three quarters of a mile from Bennett’s. Dr. Waters sent some Epsom salts by me to Mrs. Bennett; she was in bed, and seemed to be sick; think this was in October.

J. B. McRill – Blood spots at scene of murder looked “sudsy.”

Cross – Mean by “sudsy” that there was a sort of foam on the blood.

J. W. Thomas – Blood looked as if it had gushed out on the ground, as if close. Judge by having killed hogs and cattle and seeing the blood flow; saw no evidence of spattering.

William Shipton – Mr. Rusie said he turned the girl over, supposing she had fainted, and there was something wet on his hand.

Ed Beebe – (This was another of the state’s witnesses) Mr. Rusie told me he found the button a little after sunrise. Think Mrs. Bennett was washing on the well platform.

Ed Day – Saw Arthur Sherlock in Green Mountain about 9 o’clock the night of the murder; think he was getting ready to start away.

George Elliott – Saw Arthur Sherlock at Green Mountain the evening of the murder, about 9 o’clock.

Miles Clark – Anna Wiese had dark red hair, with different shades; there was a marked difference in shade; it was noticeable in a room. Appeared like a strong girl.

Cross – Have noticed the peculiarity of her hair on several occasions; there were darker shades behind the ears; front parts were lighter; hair hung down her back when I saw her.

Henry Bill – Worked for Bennett in summer and fall of 1892 and 1893. Mrs. Bennett did my washing. She would hang clothes upstairs before they were dry; sometimes she washed in the afternoon and would hang a light washing upstairs to dry, usually on the railing or banister.

Cross – The main washing had been done and my washing done afterward and hung upstairs.

Ella Roberts – Witness testified in behalf of the state. Perry Griggs said the girl’s knees were drawn up when they reached the body. Was sitting with Perry Griggs in a buggy at Henry Rusie’s when the latter came out and told Perry to go to work.

Cross – Was sent there by Ernst and Hutchins to get him to tell. The last conversation with Perry was about 5 o’clock p.m., the day of the funeral.

Wm. H. Weatherby – Henry Rusie told me the ends of the fingers were bloody after he had picked the girl up; ran from scene of murder to point two rods north of culvert in thirty-one seconds; walked from Bennett’s farm across the field to the scene of murder in fifteen minutes; through the slough would be one-third farther; the grass and weeds would not obscure a person in the day time, even lying down; did not make any trail in going down there; think I could see a man in there on his hands and knees by bright moonlight. (This in answer to juror’s question.)

Cross – Grass looked as heavy this year as last; think I could have seen a man for half a mile going through the slough in bright moonlight.

W. H. Hammond – Corroborated the previous witness relative to the difficulty of a person being obscured from view in the slough, in various positions. Nothing but the night itself would hide a person, unless lying down. I ran from Bennett’s house through the slough to the place of the murder in ten minutes and forty seconds; went as fast as I could go.

Cross by Boardman – Could not have seen a man in the slough unless I had been looking in that direction. Weeds were shorter and less frequent as you pass east and north. Think I ran three-fourths of the way from Bennett’s to the scene of the murder.

Frank Benedict – Dry goods. Button offered in evidence very common and sold for various uses; we buy men’s underwear with similar buttons on.

Cross – The ladies buy them generally.

William Stewart – Have similar buttons on my own shirt, but smaller. Have had some experience in blood drying on my hands; will take from two to four minutes; blood on my hands would not make a stain after walking six rods.

 

Cross – Think my hands were not perspiring.

Henry Stone – Know Maud Stover’s moral character in this community to be bad.

Smith Millard – Maud Stover’s moral character in the community is bad.

Samuel Bennett – No relation to defendant or her husband. Brought part of gate to town. Discovered stains on top board of gate; saw nothing to indicate that the gates had been changed. (Recognized boards in evidence as ones he had brought in.) Looked through grove in vicinity of murder with Mr. Crabtree, to look for clubs; found a number of maple clubs in Eugene Hill’s cowyard (armful here exhibited); found some at Rusie’s; found other between the two Hills’. Had nothing to match clubs except my recollection of the one found at place of murder; think similar clubs could be found in any of the maple groves in that section. Have handled blood a great deal in killing and dressing stock. Tested it in April. With my hand saturated in warm blood could make a slight stain in four minutes and none in five minutes on an undressed board; think it would dry quickest in warm weather. Don’t think a stain could be made on any board in ten minutes.

Adjourned.

SATURDAY MORNING

Cross examination of Samuel Bennett. Ran half a mile after saturating my hands with warm blood from a stuck hog; could then make a slight stain; could make none after going three-quarters of a mile; was perspiring then; found a cow yard, I think, at Rusie’s enclosing a grove. Only looked for clubs at the two Hills’ and Rusie’s.

Redirect – There is a row of trees running from Rusie’s house down to the pasture and cattle pass along a lane there. Made a test of blood recently on a damp, cool night; saturated my hands thoroughly, from sticking a sheep; started right out to travel; ran nine minutes; tried to stain a painted board and an old one; could make no stain; was perspiring at the end or the route.

H. M. Pepper sworn – My judgment is that blood will dry in from four to five minutes, if the hand is saturated; never tested it by the watch.

Cross – Time might vary one or two minutes, according to conditions of the weather or person; think perspiration would not make much difference; blood dries very rapidly.

J. W. Pepperman, ex-deputy sheriff of Grundy county – Arrived at place of murder about 9 a.m. on Sunday; was there again on Wednesday, the day of search; went through a corn field east of Bennett’s; had heard about Mrs. Sprecker having seen a man the night of the murder; I discovered a track through the corn; put my foot in it; fit my shoe, No. 8; seemed to have been made by some one going fast; I had to jump from one track to the other; followed the trail some fifteen rods; there were no other tracks; trail was in southeasterly direction, toward Mrs. Sprecker’s house; she told me she saw a man east of the house, in the road; tracks were diagonally across the corn rows; didn’t trace the track half through the field because the other men came up and spoiled the trail.

Cross – It was not a walking step; this was Wednesday forenoon; saw only the one track; saw no one in there except the men behind me; might break a little more dirt in running than walking.

Ed. Powell recalled – Had a talk with Henry Rusie ten days after the murder; said that when he reached the body he supposed she had fainted; said after the boy had gone to Hill’s he walked around the body, raised the girl’s head and placed it on his knee; am positive he said that he cried like a baby; think he said he was holding her head when the boy came back.

C. H. Smith – Clothing merchant, Marshalltown; pearl buttons like one on exhibit are used very commonly on men’s drawers; we keep them and sell them; they are sometimes used on negligee or work shirts, but not so common as on gents’ drawers.

Cross – Buttons used on undershirts are generally smaller than this.

T. A. Brown – Photographer, Marshalltown. Have taken views at scene of murder and in the vicinity. Identified a number of photos offered in evidence. Was in the neighborhood when Sam Bennett and Mr. Crabtree found the clubs. Assisted in taking top board from the gate. Have looked at hair of Anna Wiese. Mr. Ricker called my attention to it; examined it through microscope; hairs seemed to be slivered or split; splits were in some instances curled; noticed constrictions, or smaller places, in the hair.

Cross – Have used the microscope a great deal; think all the six hairs we examined showed constrictions; saw several in one hair.

James Crabtree – Witness corroborated testimony of Samuel Bennett in the matter of finding clubs, on Nov. 16, in the yards of the Hills’ and Henry Rusie.

Samuel Bennett recalled – Went up the windmill tower twenty-three feet five inches before being able to see the ground at Arthur Hill’s.

Cross – Think one might distinguish a man from a woman at that distance in daylight.

Charles Eckles – Button in evidence is very commonly used on underwear, especially on drawers; generally smaller on shirts.

Tom Allen – I climb over the gate in Bennett’s cowyard about ten days after the murder; ‘twas a three board gate, bottom and top boards broken and spliced; saw a stain, sort of walnut color, on middle board; was looking for blood stains. Blood will dry on the hand, in summer, in going seventy rods; tried it; went rapidly.

Cross – Did not know what caused the stain on the gate. Made the first blood test across our place, about four weeks after the murder.

Col. Shurtz – Think one can see the top of Bennett’s house or barn from the place of murder. Could see a man crawling through the grass on his hands and knees all the time for thirty rods, through the slough in day time. Hammond made the trip from Bennett’s to scene of murder in ten minutes and forty seconds.

Mrs. Shattuck – Sister of defendant; went there on October 13, after the murder; gathered up the soiled clothes for the wash, the blue waist in evidence among the rest; defendant was in bed; she gave no direction regarding the washing; noticed the pants button on the waist; there were no blood stains upon it; defendant was always right handed; she had trouble with her left shoulder, slipping out of joint since she was 12 years old; rheumatism seemed to settle there and bother her some; she seemed to be broken down with hard work last summer.

Cross – Had not been to visit defendant the year before the murder; only knew of her physical condition through correspondence; went to Bennett’s on Saturday and washed on Tuesday; joked with defendant about putting an old pants button on the waist; gathered up the waist with the other clothes and carried all down stairs together; Ivy Bundy washed the clothes; it was a large wash; we ironed on Thursday. Saw her arm out of joint last about twelve years ago; her health has not been very good for the past three years. Her shoulder was first thrown out of joint by playing “crack the whip” while at school. (This in answer to a juror.) Saw Ivy Bundy iron the waist.

Mr. Caswell sworn – S. K. Ernst I saw on the way to the depot with his family, moving to Missouri; took depositions of himself and son’s wife. Deposition of the latter read by Mr. Meeker; related to having seen Anna Wiese scuffle with Sam Ernst and his sons, the elder full grown, and she seemed to be about a match for anyone of them. Her hair was light and there were several shades; it was split; she was in the habit of running out bareheaded a great deal while at Ernst’s, and her hair was bleached and sunburned; her hair was curly; have noticed splits and different shades of her hair while comparing it.

Cross – Her hair had grown darker after she had left Ernst’s but there were still different shades and splits. Wore her hair banged while at Ernst’s; left there twenty months before the murder. Were simply trying their strength in fun when scuffling; would push each other backward through the room. Think her waist would measure twenty-two inches while at Ernst’s; made dresses for her; would call her hair auburn. Was timid about going out after dark alone.

Noon adjournment.

 

BURIAL PLACE OF ANNA WIESE

HELP US SOLVE THIS MURDER

THE NIGHT WATCHMAN HOMEPAGE

 

Copyright(c)2007 The Night Watchman - All Rights Reserved